protonscr

Titanic Project 401 (UE5) crashing

vkd3dclosed
HansKristian-Work/vkd3d-proton#1451 · opened 2023-03-06 by Hadrianneue · updated 2023-07-14 · 20 comments · github
HHadrianneue 2023-03-06 github

The post office is the only level that loads, every other level crashes with the following error message:
image

Software information

Titanic Project 401 page

System information

  • GPU: RX 6500 XT 4GB
  • Driver: Mesa 23.1.0-devel (git-61663859bc)
  • Wine version: Wine-GE 7-37
  • VKD3D-Proton version: 2.8

Log files

0170:fixme:rs_desc_from_d3d12: Ignoring MultisampleEnable 0x1.
01dc:info:dxgi_vk_swap_chain_recreate_swapchain_in_present_task: Got 3 swapchain images.
01f8:fixme:d3d12_device_SetResidencyPriority: iface 0000000027740030, object_count 1, objects 000000003da1ebb8, priorities 000000003da1ebc0 stub!
01f4:fixme:d3d12_device_Evict: iface 0000000027740030, object_count 32, objects 000000005010e200 stub!
01f4:fixme:d3d12_device_EnqueueMakeResident: iface 0000000027740030, flags 0, num_objects 2, objects 000000008de5d3c0, fence_to_signal 0000000000d70ad0, fence_value_to_signal 1 stub!
0178:fixme:vk_samples_from_dxgi_sample_desc: Unhandled sample count 0.
0174:fixme:vk_samples_from_dxgi_sample_desc: Unhandled sample count 0.
Monitored process exited.
Initial process has exited (return code: 768)
Exit with return code 768
Aadolfintel 2023-03-06 github

Same problem here with the current master

Ddoitsujin maintainer 2023-03-06 github

Can you please post a full Proton log? The snippet doesn't point to there being any issue on our end and "shader compilation" can either be d3dcompiler memes or some actual d3d12 problem.

Mmbriar 2023-03-06 github

log.txt

BBananaWorks07 2023-03-08 github

could someone try using native d3dcompiler

Aadolfintel 2023-03-09 github

Tried replacing wine's d3dcompiler_47.dll with the one from Windows 10 64 bit and launching the game with WINEDLLOVERRIDES="d3dcompiler_47=n,b". No effect

Mmbriar 2023-03-09 github

It doesn't load any d3dcompiler dll.

HHadrianneue 2023-07-10 github

seems to be working fine now, no errors, i have no idea why....

Llucilanga 2023-07-10 github

seems to be working fine now, no errors, i have no idea why....

how did you run it ?

HHadrianneue 2023-07-10 github

seems to be working fine now, no errors, i have no idea why....

how did you run it ?

vkd3d-git and mesa git and wine-ge 8.7 with lutris, but i have no idea for how long this has been working, i just decided to re-test it now

Aadolfintel 2023-07-10 github

I can confirm that this works now with the latest vkd3d and mesa-git. I'm not really an expert but if I had to guess, I'd say it's that commit that implemented ROV in mesa that fixed this and other games a few weeks ago.

HHadrianneue 2023-07-10 github

I can confirm that this works now with the latest vkd3d and mesa-git. I'm not really an expert but if I had to guess, I'd say it's that commit that implemented ROV in mesa that fixed this and other games a few weeks ago.

which one exactly? i can try building mesa without and do a test.

Aadolfintel 2023-07-10 github

@Hadrianneue This MR https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/mesa/mesa/-/merge_requests/22250

HHadrianneue 2023-07-10 github

@Hadrianneue This MR https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/mesa/mesa/-/merge_requests/22250

i did a build by commenting out references to that extension on radv_physical_device.c, vulkaninfo shows interlock as false, i'm not a 100% sure its disabled but game still runs, tried amdvlk (doesn't support shader interlock currently) and it runs on latest vkd3d, even tried the older vkd3d 2.8 (git release) and game still runs...

maybe its something on RADV but idk

Aadolfintel 2023-07-10 github

Do a git bisect on mesa: find a commit that doesn't work and start bisecting from there. If you can't find one prior to when the issue was reported, then it's vkd3d that fixed this issue and you should do the bisect on this project instead.

HHadrianneue 2023-07-10 github

Do a git bisect on mesa: find a commit that doesn't work and start bisecting from there. If you can't find one prior to when the issue was reported, then it's vkd3d that fixed this issue and you should do the bisect on this project instead.

yeah im aware, but my setup with aur makes doing that a PITA...

Aadolfintel 2023-07-10 github

Well, it's not ideal, but if you want to do it through your aur helper, you can just modify the pkgbuild file to build a specific commit.
It's kinda stupid and very manual but if you don't want to build mesa manually it's better than nothing.

vkd3d on the other hand is super easy to build and bisect.

HHadrianneue 2023-07-10 github

Well, it's not ideal, but if you want to do it through your aur helper, you can just modify the pkgbuild file to build a specific commit. It's kinda stupid and very manual but if you don't want to build mesa manually it's better than nothing.

vkd3d on the other hand is super easy to build and bisect.

i'll bisect it then later on today (tomorrow) after work, it shouldn't take too long.

Ffakhraldin 2023-07-11 github

Hi, any news about this? I got the exact same error message after crashing. Only the level post office does work.
My system setup is Fedora 38 with following specs.:
GPU: RX 6600 8GB
Driver: Mesa 23.1.3
Wine version: lutris-GE-Proton8-10
VKD3D-Proton version: 2.9
winelog-TitanicDemo401V2.txt

I get the same error message on another UE5 (v5.1) based Demo here.:
https://github.com/HansKristian-Work/vkd3d-proton/issues/1599
and another issue based on UEv5.2 here.:
https://github.com/HansKristian-Work/vkd3d-proton/issues/1598

HHadrianneue 2023-07-11 github

found it, fixed on mesa: https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/mesa/mesa/-/commit/91505132423bcf8949034ef277b8bee4e1936855

@fakhraldin update to mesa-git if possible, it will likely fix your issue with UE 5.2 demo too.

Ffakhraldin 2023-07-14 github

@Hadrianneue I installed latest mesa-git and the UE 5.1 Demo works now, as well as two other UE5.(1) based games.
One of them started only with parameter -vulkan before. Now both run with -dx12. That hints to a vkd3d fix.

The UE5.2 Demo though starts sometimes now, but crashes after a couple of seconds.
Thank you for your testing and feedback.

PS: maybe also related to mesa fixes or maybe due to vkd3d fixes, the UE4 game "stray" with parameter -dx12 works now too.

Proton versions

Launch options

Upstream links

DLLs