protonscr

Feature Request: Dota 2

steamclosed Feature Requestreviewed
ValveSoftware/steam-for-linux#438 · opened 2012-12-28 by BadPractice · updated 2019-07-18 · 134 comments · github
BBadPractice 2012-12-28 github

Since i would love a Dota 2 on Steam/Linux i did some research and it seems like A LOT of other users would love that too. May be worth a consideration.

Edit: I should mention that the Windows Version of Dota 2 can be emulated with WineHQ quite good.
see: http://appdb.winehq.org/objectManager.php?sClass=version&iId=24458

MMrSchism 2012-12-28 github

Dota 2 uses a newer version of the Source engine than what is currently ported... and a specially modified version at that, from my understanding.

It may be some time before it winds up on Linux, but it's coming.

GGrammidin 2013-01-02 github

+100500
If you see DotA 2 under Linux - I will remove Windows :)

WWizek 2013-01-04 github
+:100:
EEvilMaster 2013-01-19 github

+1

Ddimazanyat 2013-02-02 github

+100

Jjonaias 2013-02-04 github

Waiting for that!

Aaviau 2013-02-04 github

I wouldn't commit on deleting Windows, but I would certainly swtich to Linux as my main OS.
I have been waiting on this moment for a decade. DotA2 on Linux will change my life, really.

AAce5040 2013-02-04 github

+1
Would be nice to read some official comments about that issue.
Dota 2 is the best game ever. Keep up a good work Valve)

Sshideneyu 2013-02-04 github

I threw windows a few years ago. Can't play at Dota2 on linux, waiting for this =)
+1

CCommonOddity 2013-02-05 github

+1

@ shideneyu

You can play it with Wine. That is what I am doing right now (with high settings and an Nvidia GTX 460 it runs surprisingly well). Can't wait for it to be natively available for Linux.

Sshideneyu 2013-02-06 github

@CommonOddity

Thanks, I tried to install it a few months ago. Due to the old wine version probably, I tries many things, spent 5 hours or so to install it, made many changes on my computer, and I have ended to have a black screen when opening my computer... due to the bad installed driver for my graphic card. That day, I reinstalled everything to get a clean install and I've never talked about Dota2 anymore.
Your post made me want to retry a last time, and it worked =D ! Thanks, it works nicely and very smoothly with my Nvidia GT 630M, a bit long to charge and got to remove Compiz, installing vcrun2010 and that's it. This time, I decided not to go too far in the changes I got to do. Thanks again ;)

Sorry for polluting the thread, still waiting for Dota2 on Linux natively for other guys who couldn't run it !

NNoMore201 2013-02-13 github

Tried with wine, perfect but with some small graphical glitches. +1 Dota 2 for linux !!!

BBoPuNk 2013-02-13 github

+1 waiting for Dota 2 on Linux! i will say definitely bye to windows and bill gate!!!!
SUPPORT!

Nnitaigao 2013-02-14 github

+1 Dota for Linux. I'll even do the merge for you if you let me Valve!

Hhakksel 2013-02-14 github

+1

Ss4ke 2013-02-15 github

+1

GGeriain 2013-02-15 github

+1 sick of emulating evrything with wine!

Jjaison 2013-02-15 github

+1

Hhspak 2013-02-15 github

+1

Ccf8 2013-02-15 github

+1
Subscribing

Eeojthejudge 2013-02-16 github

+1

Ttexaco 2013-02-16 github

me too

Ddevova 2013-02-16 github

+1

GGlenFoxBomb 2013-02-17 github

I will remove windows once this is native :+1:

SSpielzeug 2013-02-17 github

+1

BBiohZn 2013-02-17 github

+1

Ssh4nks 2013-02-17 github

+1

BBiosElement 2013-02-17 github

+1 subbing, Would love to see this.

Ssaward 2013-02-18 github

+1

Ssergy-gzh 2013-02-18 github

+1

EEzwen 2013-02-18 github

+1

Nnirjharo 2013-02-18 github
Tteo-sk 2013-02-19 github

+1

Rrykugur 2013-02-19 github

+1

PPauloFerreira25 2013-02-19 github

+1

Mmpadovani 2013-02-19 github

+1
Come Dota 2 on linux please.

Ddhilst 2013-02-19 github

+1

Llawnsoldier 2013-02-20 github

+1

?ghost 2013-02-20 github

+1

Aatatsu 2013-02-20 github

+1

SsRaH 2013-02-20 github

+1

Kkarshan 2013-02-20 github

+1

MMrSchism 2013-02-21 github

These "+1" comments aren't really useful at the moment. Valve is aware that Dota 2 is desired and it will come in time. If you're just "+1"ing for the sake of following the conversation, you can watch/unwatch the issue by scrolling to the bottom of the page and clicking the area where it says "Watch thread" (or, for those who want to unwatch, select "Unwatch thread".

Every time someone "+1"s this, the development team gets an email which just adds up and distracts the developers.

Bbugcook 2013-02-21 github

+1

PPauloFerreira25 2013-02-21 github

Hi MrSchism,

Thanks for your reply and your clarification.

If the development does not want to receive any more emails, I believe the best solution would be to give a date for Valve when intending to make this launch. So avoid staff come here and put +1 indicating that it is one more person who is interested.

For the fact of being put +1 this only to indicate that a person is more similar to a vote. If the idea get perhaps all projects end up having a list +1 where people would put their vote for who should go first.

Sincerely,

Obs: Sorry for my english...

Paulo Ferreira.
+1 Dota 2 for linux

MMrSchism 2013-02-21 github

There's no date available; it'll come when it comes. The Steam-for-Linux guys are breaking Valve tradition by actually setting accurate milestones (for those familiar with Valve Time, you'll understand). It's known that people are interested. There's just no publicly (and probably no internally) known window for when Dota2 will be available, so there's no date to be posted here. That's the main difference between expected dates (traditional) and milestones (git-development standard).

It's unlikely that the amount of +1's will have any effect on when Dota 2 gets ported; Dota2 is still technically in an invite-only beta AND is still in active development. The version of the Source engine is not ported over yet; as-is, we're only seeing Source1 and GoldSrc games on the Linux client... and even then, not all of them.

Dota2 is coming, +1 or not. You could have 100,000 +1's and still wouldn't change too much because it's not ready yet. Just be patient.

PPauloFerreira25 2013-02-21 github

MrSchism, I understand your point of view. But you did not understand mine.

The +1 here are being effective, because if it were not troublesome, you would not need to come here and "teach" you how to stop sending emails.

I believe that until we have a date, people will come here and put +1 know why it bothers. It would be the same thing as making a "rally" in front of Valve, may not have direct effect, more uncomfortable.

Just gave suggestion on how to solve your problem (email in your inbox).

Overall, I believe that talking to the client, "is a quiet day turns" is not an effective way to treat your customer.

But who am I to judge right?

Sincerely,

Paulo Ferreira.
+1 Dota 2 for linux

MMrSchism 2013-02-22 github

I believe that until we have a date, people will come here and put +1 know why it bothers. It would be the same thing as making a "rally" in front of Valve, may not have direct effect, more uncomfortable.

That'd be like people rallying in front of Pepsi and demanding that they keep making cola.

BBadPractice 2013-02-22 github

Thanks for the commends

@ PauloFerreira25: Valve will not give a date. They will be finished when they think they are. You should appreciated that concept because it is the reason why Valve games barely have bugs. I highly encourage them not to give a release date and keep up there system (and there snack fridge).

@ MrSchism Let people post there +1. They dont hurt anybody. Best case is they help Valve to set there priorities. Worst case they just tell the fans including me that they are not alone

I'm fully aware that Valve is may working on the Linux client right at this moment but without making it public. Actually i think the chance of that is very high

MMrSchism 2013-02-22 github

@ MrSchism Let people post there +1. They dont hurt anybody. Best case is they help Valve to set there priorities. Worst case they just tell the fans including me that they are not alone

No. It just floods the inbox of every moderator and every developer assigned to this repository with emails that just say "+1"

BBadPractice 2013-02-22 github

@ MrSchism Good point! Its flooting mine too. But i still like them.

?ghost 2013-02-22 github

Plus Ones are a well understood phenomenon on internet mailing lists and
bug trackers.

Without exception, a +1 is hugely negative thing to post. It doesn't help
anyone and often results in developers actively unwatching a thread so that
their limited time isn't diverted by useless spam.

Every +1 posted diverts someone's attention from bringing DOTA2 to linux.

The irony is obvious.

On 22 February 2013 15:21, Philipp Hufnagl [email protected] wrote:

@ MrSchism Good point! Its flooting mine too. But i still like them.


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/ValveSoftware/steam-for-linux/issues/438#issuecomment-13948091.

*Do not me Word attachments in email
See http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/no-word-attachments.html
*

PPauloFerreira25 2013-02-22 github

@BadPractice, spoke only to give a date, because this is a solution to not having much more email.

There are others, such as having a website where people can go there and talk that are waiting (oops, I think it's already seen it somewhere).

PPauloFerreira25 2013-02-22 github

In short, what is happening is:

  1. We have customers, we want to demonstrate that we are wanting a game.
  2. Valve does not have a tool for this. Should you have a page with the name of the game and each customer can put +1 in your game.
  3. You @MrSchism, which is sentative Valve (I hope) ought to address our request to the team resonsavel and not simply settle and say, Stop sending me email.

The Valve depends on customers, and customers of the games. If there is no game client, and thus has no $ $ $. The Valve is entering the Linux market because of $ $ $, if not to take the "free help" we are demonstrating on where to get more $ $ $, then I believe that Valve will try to follow the same path as Microsoft launch what he wants, how he wants and when he wants, and thus lose their market. As is happening in migrating from Windows to Linux.

In short, sir @MrSchism, please do your part. Stop complaining and send it to your boss to our request, propose a solution to the customer instead of just saying:

"Please stop talking."

Dota 2 is only one of the game if all games do, oh yes your inbox will be full.

MMrSchism 2013-02-23 github
  1. I don't work for Valve; I am a community moderator who spends 4-10 hours here any given day.
  2. You don't need to vote for them porting Dota2 because they already are porting it. They are working on it. They need to get the simpler games ported over first or else Dota2 won't be playable for considerably longer.
  3. I never said "Please stop talking." I said that the +1 comments are useless; real discussion is not forbidden.
Ssaward 2013-02-23 github

@MrSchism do you have the power to close this issue? If they're already working on it, I agree there's no point having this exist any more. The arguments in favour of keeping it going seem silly.

MMrSchism 2013-02-23 github

It will stay open until they either:

  1. Mark it for a milestone. Once it gets marked for a milestone, it'll progress on here until it reaches the milestone. At that point, it'll be automatically closed and the game will be released
  2. Release Dota2 for linux without tracking here. It will be then closed manually.

The issue is that the version of Source that Dota2 uses is pretty specialized and will take a TON of work as compared to GoldSrc/Source-1.

Cchmerces 2013-03-07 github

+1 from Brazil, #byewindows

UUseLinux 2013-03-10 github

+1 make Dota2 available to Linux platforms.

?ghost 2013-03-10 github

+1

Ggmanrainy 2013-03-12 github

+1

Llayus 2013-03-13 github

+1

MMitmischer 2013-03-13 github

+:100:

Mmpiatka 2013-03-16 github

+1

Bborisdamato 2013-03-18 github

+1

TToothlessGear 2013-03-21 github

+1

Mmcclaskc 2013-03-21 github

I want to leave windows in the dust! +1

Bbiji 2013-03-22 github

pssstt.. beta version for linux will be released mid year

TTorxed 2013-03-23 github

I'll endorse this for sure!

Nnitaigao 2013-03-24 github

Steam for linux has been released to the general public, there is no beta

PPesthaf 2013-03-24 github

+1

MMrSchism 2013-03-25 github

Steam for linux has been released to the general public, there is no beta

The reference was to the Dota 2 beta client on linux.

Ggrandon 2013-03-25 github

+1

Mmittmannv8 2013-03-26 github

+1

Ggjgfuj 2013-03-27 github

I would really like to finally put some time into this game, because the only place I have been able to play it was at a friend who had windows' place.

EDIT: So +1

Jjoostruis 2013-03-31 github

+1

DDmitryBochkarev 2013-04-01 github

+1

DDaVince 2013-04-03 github

Not a feature.

MMrSchism 2013-04-03 github

Linux compatibility is a feature requested for Dota 2.

Ggoodn1ght 2013-04-09 github

+1

AAlexWindHope 2013-04-16 github

+1
Dota 2 is the only one reason why i have windows installed on my machine.

EEsqvatn 2013-04-17 github

+1

?ghost 2013-04-18 github

+1

Eeidast 2013-04-21 github

+1 y me vuelo de una Windows :dancers: :D

Wwyqydsyq 2013-04-23 github

:+1: +1

Aa1batross 2013-04-26 github

+1! Want!

?ghost 2013-04-28 github

dota2 is probably the last thing i need to switch away from windows. +1!

Ddaniel-ferradal-marquez 2013-05-01 github

+1

Add me to the list!

BBKPepe 2013-05-06 github

+1

Pporkaria 2013-05-06 github

+1

Rrenanmira 2013-05-06 github

+1

Ggustavomrs 2013-05-06 github

+1

MMasterTroller 2013-05-06 github

+1

JJiminimonka 2013-05-07 github

Definitely +5

Yyoyosan 2013-05-08 github

Pretty please.

Ffnantes 2013-05-08 github

please! +1

Eedumelzer 2013-05-16 github

+1

Lleamarty 2013-05-16 github

+1

Rresure 2013-05-16 github

+1

FfebLey 2013-05-17 github

+1

GGrey2k 2013-05-20 github

+100

Ssquisher 2013-05-20 github

+1

Eeyenx 2013-05-22 github

+1

Eedwinlunando 2013-06-02 github

+1
With DotA 2 on Linux, I'll burn my windows. :D.

Mmichaelsund 2013-06-03 github

1++

Ggarrett85 2013-06-04 github

What is DotA 2?

MMrSchism 2013-06-05 github

If that's a serious question, it's a game. The first one was a Warcraft III mod called Defense of the Ancients. The sequel was made using a customized Source engine. It's a Multiplayer Online Battle Arena (MOBA)/ Action Real Time Strategy (ARTS) game. It's technically still in Beta, but it's a popular freemium (free-to-play, cash for specific in-game content) game with a strong following as an eSport.

Due to the complexity and specificity of its Source version and current issues regarding drivers and Source on linux, it'll probably still be a while before its released. If they release it soon, it'll probably perform poorly and will likely flood the bugtracker.

(The above consists of personal opinions and is not necessarily the opinion of Valve software, its employees, or its affiliates.)

Mmyscienceisbetter 2013-06-06 github

+1

Ddhilst 2013-06-07 github

Valve would open things that is not valve specific so the community can help, this may improve the release date.. still is in Valve charge decide what is what is not "openable" but certainly there are things that community can help. I know I'm nobody to say what Valve would do but, this may replace the useless +1 comments to something more usefull like bug reports..

Cheers,

Ppplcf 2013-06-08 github

gaben gib doto

GGRBurst 2013-06-08 github

+1

I would love to have Dota 2 on Linux (Steam), too!

PS: I've searched all comments now - could not find a steam-group which belongs to this. Because of that I created a steam-group named Dota 2 on Linux and made a quick logo - for those who are interested ;)

+1

JJerzySpendel 2013-06-08 github

+1

MMailaender 2013-06-09 github

It would be interesting to hear about the real technical challenges Valve is facing in this port, not just "it is hard to do", "currently very buggy", "engine is not identical to Source shooters".

Kksthiele 2013-06-09 github

+1

I'm pretty sure it will come at some point

PPauloFerreira25 2013-06-09 github

MrSchism, só você acha que estamos brincando.

JJenniferPylko 2013-06-11 github

Since Dota 2 and CS:GO came out around the same time, it would stand to reason that they have similar engines. If I remember correctly, Portal 2 was upgraded to the CS:GO engine. So these 3 games will probably come out around the same time for Linux.

Fflenzi 2013-06-14 github

+1

Aanandrkris 2013-06-17 github

+1

Wwuerges 2013-06-24 github

+1

Aalexand7u 2013-07-03 github

+1

00x726f62 2013-07-06 github

+1
i would love to play dota2 with native client.
i am getting tired with wine and sound bugs caused by alsa/pulseaudio

Jjoostruis 2013-07-10 github

http://www.dota2.com/thebetaisover/

Q: Will Dota 2 be available for Mac or Linux?
A: The Mac and Linux builds are currently in testing and will be available soon.

Vvedranmiletic 2013-07-10 github

Awesome.

00x726f62 2013-07-10 github

soon ... i genuinely hate that word

AAlexWindHope 2013-07-10 github

Well, soon is much better than who knows :)

Jjohndrinkwater 2013-07-10 github

Soon is soon, I’m going to close this bug and point users to https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Dota-2/issues for when the client is released we’ll be taking Mac and Linux bug reports there. Please be generous with your patience and reserved with your commenting, thank you!

BBadPractice 2013-07-11 github

Arr... its not a bug report its a feature request. Thanks anyway. Looking forward to play Dota 2 naively on Linux

Nnirjharo 2013-07-11 github

Dota 2 test .. Released on Steam for Linux.
Checkout:
http://m.webupd8.org/2013/07/dota-2-test-available-for-linux-steam.html
On Jul 11, 2013 4:12 PM, "Philipp Hufnagl" [email protected]
wrote:

Arr... its not a bug report its a feature request. Thanks anyway. Looking
forward to play Dota 2 naively on Linux


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/ValveSoftware/steam-for-linux/issues/438#issuecomment-20803080
.

NNickPaul41 2013-07-11 github

Yep, it's released. I played it last night.

-Nick Paul

On Thu, Jul 11, 2013 at 6:03 AM, nirjharoberoi [email protected]:

Dota 2 test .. Released on Steam for Linux.
Checkout:
http://m.webupd8.org/2013/07/dota-2-test-available-for-linux-steam.html
On Jul 11, 2013 4:12 PM, "Philipp Hufnagl" [email protected]
wrote:

Arr... its not a bug report its a feature request. Thanks anyway.
Looking
forward to play Dota 2 naively on Linux


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub<
https://github.com/ValveSoftware/steam-for-linux/issues/438#issuecomment-20803080>

.


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/ValveSoftware/steam-for-linux/issues/438#issuecomment-20803970
.

Cchmerces 2013-07-11 github

I will test now!
Eu vou testar agora!

Vvitali2y 2013-07-13 github

+1 4 native

Ssajjadrad 2013-07-13 github

+1
The closing is a very good news:D

Aa1batross 2013-07-22 github

This shit game is not works for me. Hm... I need for new video card.