And here's another reason why we don't support Windows. It's a known problem. EnumDisplaySettingsW just doesn't seem to work as expected but I'm not aware of any other way to query display modes (especially the current display more) without using Microsoft's DXGI.
Hmm.. Okay.
I couldn't find a bug report about it.
Is there no way to do a manual workaround and just select a refresh rate and save it in a config file?
No, and I don't plan to add one. I'd rather like to know why this just doesn't work on Windows. I don't have a high refresh rate display and no multi-monitor setup, so I can't reproduce this problem and therefore also not debug it.
Can you run the dxgi-factory test app from DXVK and post the console output? Here's a build if you need: dxgi-factory.exe.zip
Sure. Here's the output:
<
Adapter 0:
AMD Radeon RX 5700 XT
Vendor: 4098
Device: 29471
Dedicated RAM: 8185974784
Shared RAM: 17150607360
Output 0:
\.\DISPLAY1
Coordinates: 0,0:2560x1440
640x480 @ 60
640x480 @ 60 (native)
640x480 @ 60
640x480 @ 100
640x480 @ 100 (native)
640x480 @ 100
640x480 @ 120
640x480 @ 120 (native)
640x480 @ 120
640x480 @ 144
640x480 @ 144 (native)
640x480 @ 144
720x480 @ 60
720x480 @ 60 (native)
720x480 @ 60
720x480 @ 100
720x480 @ 100 (native)
720x480 @ 100
720x480 @ 120
720x480 @ 120 (native)
720x480 @ 120
720x480 @ 144
720x480 @ 144 (native)
720x480 @ 144
800x600 @ 60
800x600 @ 60 (native)
800x600 @ 60
800x600 @ 100
800x600 @ 100 (native)
800x600 @ 100
800x600 @ 120
800x600 @ 120 (native)
800x600 @ 120
800x600 @ 144
800x600 @ 144 (native)
800x600 @ 144
1024x768 @ 60
1024x768 @ 60 (native)
1024x768 @ 60
1024x768 @ 100
1024x768 @ 100 (native)
1024x768 @ 100
1024x768 @ 120
1024x768 @ 120 (native)
1024x768 @ 120
1024x768 @ 144
1024x768 @ 144 (native)
1024x768 @ 144
1152x864 @ 60
1152x864 @ 60 (native)
1152x864 @ 60
1152x864 @ 100
1152x864 @ 100 (native)
1152x864 @ 100
1152x864 @ 120
1152x864 @ 120 (native)
1152x864 @ 120
1152x864 @ 144
1152x864 @ 144 (native)
1152x864 @ 144
1280x720 @ 60
1280x720 @ 60 (native)
1280x720 @ 60
1280x720 @ 100
1280x720 @ 100 (native)
1280x720 @ 100
1280x720 @ 120
1280x720 @ 120 (native)
1280x720 @ 120
1280x720 @ 144
1280x720 @ 144 (native)
1280x720 @ 144
1280x800 @ 60
1280x800 @ 60 (native)
1280x800 @ 60
1280x800 @ 100
1280x800 @ 100 (native)
1280x800 @ 100
1280x800 @ 120
1280x800 @ 120 (native)
1280x800 @ 120
1280x800 @ 144
1280x800 @ 144 (native)
1280x800 @ 144
1280x1024 @ 60
1280x1024 @ 60 (native)
1280x1024 @ 60
1280x1024 @ 100
1280x1024 @ 100 (native)
1280x1024 @ 100
1280x1024 @ 120
1280x1024 @ 120 (native)
1280x1024 @ 120
1280x1024 @ 144
1280x1024 @ 144 (native)
1280x1024 @ 144
1366x768 @ 60
1366x768 @ 60 (native)
1366x768 @ 60
1366x768 @ 100
1366x768 @ 100 (native)
1366x768 @ 100
1366x768 @ 120
1366x768 @ 120 (native)
1366x768 @ 120
1366x768 @ 144
1366x768 @ 144 (native)
1366x768 @ 144
1600x900 @ 60
1600x900 @ 60 (native)
1600x900 @ 60
1600x900 @ 100
1600x900 @ 100 (native)
1600x900 @ 100
1600x900 @ 120
1600x900 @ 120 (native)
1600x900 @ 120
1600x900 @ 144
1600x900 @ 144 (native)
1600x900 @ 144
1600x1200 @ 60
1600x1200 @ 60 (native)
1600x1200 @ 60
1600x1200 @ 100
1600x1200 @ 100 (native)
1600x1200 @ 100
1600x1200 @ 120
1600x1200 @ 120 (native)
1600x1200 @ 120
1600x1200 @ 144
1600x1200 @ 144 (native)
1600x1200 @ 144
1680x1050 @ 60
1680x1050 @ 60 (native)
1680x1050 @ 60
1680x1050 @ 100
1680x1050 @ 100 (native)
1680x1050 @ 100
1680x1050 @ 120
1680x1050 @ 120 (native)
1680x1050 @ 120
1680x1050 @ 144
1680x1050 @ 144 (native)
1680x1050 @ 144
1920x1080 @ 60
1920x1080 @ 60 (native)
1920x1080 @ 60
1920x1080 @ 100
1920x1080 @ 100 (native)
1920x1080 @ 100
1920x1080 @ 120
1920x1080 @ 120 (native)
1920x1080 @ 120
1920x1080 @ 144
1920x1080 @ 144 (native)
1920x1080 @ 144
1920x1200 @ 60
1920x1200 @ 60 (native)
1920x1200 @ 60
1920x1200 @ 100
1920x1200 @ 100 (native)
1920x1200 @ 100
1920x1200 @ 120
1920x1200 @ 120 (native)
1920x1200 @ 120
1920x1200 @ 144
1920x1200 @ 144 (native)
1920x1200 @ 144
2560x1440 @ 60
2560x1440 @ 100
2560x1440 @ 120
2560x1440 @ 144
Adapter 1:
Microsoft Basic Render Driver
Vendor: 5140
Device: 140
Dedicated RAM: 0
Shared RAM: 17150607360
Ah, sorry, I should have been clearer - please run it with DXVK, i.e. with dxgi.dll next to the executable.
Also, multiline code blocks on github work with three backticks, see here.
ah, okay. One moment then
info: Game: dxgi-factory.exe
info: DXVK: v1.7.3
info: Built-in extension providers:
info: Win32 WSI
info: OpenVR
warn: OpenVR: Failed to locate module
info: Enabled instance extensions:
info: VK_KHR_get_surface_capabilities2
info: VK_KHR_surface
info: VK_KHR_win32_surface
info: AMD Radeon RX 5700 XT:
info: Driver: 2.0.168
info: Vulkan: 1.2.162
info: Memory Heap[0]:
info: Size: 7920 MiB
info: Flags: 0x3
info: Memory Type[0]: Property Flags = 0x1
info: Memory Type[4]: Property Flags = 0xc1
info: Memory Heap[1]:
info: Size: 16100 MiB
info: Flags: 0x0
info: Memory Type[1]: Property Flags = 0x6
info: Memory Type[3]: Property Flags = 0xe
info: Memory Type[5]: Property Flags = 0xc6
info: Memory Type[7]: Property Flags = 0xce
info: Memory Heap[2]:
info: Size: 256 MiB
info: Flags: 0x3
info: Memory Type[2]: Property Flags = 0x7
info: Memory Type[6]: Property Flags = 0xc7
Adapter 0:
AMD Radeon RX 5700 XT
Vendor: 4098
Device: 29471
Dedicated RAM: 8573157376
Shared RAM: 16882073600
Output 0:
\\.\DISPLAY1
Coordinates: 0,0:2560x1440
640x480 @ 60
640x480 @ 60
640x480 @ 60
640x480 @ 100
640x480 @ 100
640x480 @ 100
640x480 @ 120
640x480 @ 120
640x480 @ 120
640x480 @ 144
640x480 @ 144
640x480 @ 144
720x480 @ 60
720x480 @ 60
720x480 @ 60
720x480 @ 100
720x480 @ 100
720x480 @ 100
720x480 @ 120
720x480 @ 120
720x480 @ 120
720x480 @ 144
720x480 @ 144
720x480 @ 144
800x600 @ 60
800x600 @ 60
800x600 @ 60
800x600 @ 100
800x600 @ 100
800x600 @ 100
800x600 @ 120
800x600 @ 120
800x600 @ 120
800x600 @ 144
800x600 @ 144
800x600 @ 144
1024x768 @ 60
1024x768 @ 60
1024x768 @ 60
1024x768 @ 100
1024x768 @ 100
1024x768 @ 100
1024x768 @ 120
1024x768 @ 120
1024x768 @ 120
1024x768 @ 144
1024x768 @ 144
1024x768 @ 144
1152x864 @ 60
1152x864 @ 60
1152x864 @ 60
1152x864 @ 100
1152x864 @ 100
1152x864 @ 100
1152x864 @ 120
1152x864 @ 120
1152x864 @ 120
1152x864 @ 144
1152x864 @ 144
1152x864 @ 144
1280x720 @ 60
1280x720 @ 60
1280x720 @ 60
1280x720 @ 100
1280x720 @ 100
1280x720 @ 100
1280x720 @ 120
1280x720 @ 120
1280x720 @ 120
1280x720 @ 144
1280x720 @ 144
1280x720 @ 144
1280x800 @ 60
1280x800 @ 60
1280x800 @ 60
1280x800 @ 100
1280x800 @ 100
1280x800 @ 100
1280x800 @ 120
1280x800 @ 120
1280x800 @ 120
1280x800 @ 144
1280x800 @ 144
1280x800 @ 144
1280x1024 @ 60
1280x1024 @ 60
1280x1024 @ 60
1280x1024 @ 100
1280x1024 @ 100
1280x1024 @ 100
1280x1024 @ 120
1280x1024 @ 120
1280x1024 @ 120
1280x1024 @ 144
1280x1024 @ 144
1280x1024 @ 144
1366x768 @ 60
1366x768 @ 60
1366x768 @ 60
1366x768 @ 100
1366x768 @ 100
1366x768 @ 100
1366x768 @ 120
1366x768 @ 120
1366x768 @ 120
1366x768 @ 144
1366x768 @ 144
1366x768 @ 144
1600x900 @ 60
1600x900 @ 60
1600x900 @ 60
1600x900 @ 100
1600x900 @ 100
1600x900 @ 100
1600x900 @ 120
1600x900 @ 120
1600x900 @ 120
1600x900 @ 144
1600x900 @ 144
1600x900 @ 144
1600x1200 @ 60
1600x1200 @ 60
1600x1200 @ 60
1600x1200 @ 100
1600x1200 @ 100
1600x1200 @ 100
1600x1200 @ 120
1600x1200 @ 120
1600x1200 @ 120
1600x1200 @ 144
1600x1200 @ 144
1600x1200 @ 144
1680x1050 @ 60
1680x1050 @ 60
1680x1050 @ 60
1680x1050 @ 100
1680x1050 @ 100
1680x1050 @ 100
1680x1050 @ 120
1680x1050 @ 120
1680x1050 @ 120
1680x1050 @ 144
1680x1050 @ 144
1680x1050 @ 144
1920x1080 @ 60
1920x1080 @ 60
1920x1080 @ 60
1920x1080 @ 100
1920x1080 @ 100
1920x1080 @ 100
1920x1080 @ 120
1920x1080 @ 120
1920x1080 @ 120
1920x1080 @ 144
1920x1080 @ 144
1920x1080 @ 144
1920x1200 @ 60
1920x1200 @ 60
1920x1200 @ 60
1920x1200 @ 100
1920x1200 @ 100
1920x1200 @ 100
1920x1200 @ 120
1920x1200 @ 120
1920x1200 @ 120
1920x1200 @ 144
1920x1200 @ 144
1920x1200 @ 144
2560x1440 @ 60
2560x1440 @ 100
2560x1440 @ 120
2560x1440 @ 144
Yeah, so, it does actually detect the 120 and 144 Hz modes correctly. Note that we currently only report one monitor because wine used to have issues with multi-monitor setups in the past and we haven't enabled multi-monitor stuff in DXGI yet.
So yeah, no idea why it would switch to a 60 Hz mode, but I cannot debug this any further.
That's unfortunate, but understandable.
As my own workaround, I just deleted the other lower refresh rates reported by my monitor's EDID to get it to stay at 120Hz for now. That seems to keep it at whatever refresh rate Windows reports as the lowest.
This is a long standing unresolved bug of Windows 10, which does not happen on Windows 7.
On Win10, Vulkan is locked to 60 Hz. Forcing another refresh rate (via Hotkey Resolution Changer for example) will result in a blank screen and the game/app trying to switch back to 60 Hz.
For info, it is not specific to dxvk, it occurs in all native Vulkan apps (RDR2, Detroit, RPCS3...).
Yeah, I've been reading about it too.
Doesn't look like a way to expose the current refresh rate to Vulkan in Windows currently.
I've not been getting a blank screen when I deleted the 60Hz from my EDID for my monitor. Checking the OSD of the monitor confirms that it's still boosting to 120Hz while in game with DXVK as well, so the solution works but maybe only for my configuration.
It does flicker, but I assumed Vulkan is refreshing the screen whenever it gets in/out of focus, as I can alt-tab out of it and still see the game running in the background but whenever I alt-tab in or out, the screen flickers.
For info, it is not specific to dxvk, it occurs in all native Vulkan apps (RDR2, Detroit, RPCS3...).
No it doesn't. I played Doom Eternal at 120hz just fine and I've also had DXVK games running at 120hz on Windows.
It doesn't for you, you're lucky. It happens to most Win10 users.
Windows is a crap. Just leave this leaky ship.
@mozo78 Can you please stop shitting on Windows in every single Windows related issue? It adds absolutely nothing to the discussion and is frankly just annoying.
It's annoyng but it's true. Windows threads in a Linux project are also very irritating. If they are want to use DXVK - they are very welcome - install Linux and go!
@K0bin
No it doesn't. I played Doom Eternal at 120hz just fine ...
@mozo78 Can you please stop shitting on Windows in every single Windows related issue? It adds absolutely nothing to the discussion and is frankly just annoying.
You know what else annoying? Your "works for me, not our problem" comments (while using Windows all the time).
p.s. I know Windows is fake, because I use Linux. I know PE builds are useless, because I played no single game with PE build. Trust me. jk, I know mileage may vary for every single user.
You could try forcing a higher refresh rate by adding a custom resolution, and make it have only one refresh option available.
Interesting to see confirmation of the 3x refresh rate listing on an AMD GPU as well. I get this on an Nvidia 1080 Ti with my 144hz monitor. Every resolution and refresh rate listing gets 3 entries in the reported display modes list. This is a major problem for specific games that have a limited entry table capacity and you end up being stuck at a lower resolution, for me it's typically 1280x1024 @ 100hz on my 2560x1440 144hz monitor.
Also, this 60hz bug can happen on Nvidia however the Nvidia driver has an option to override the application requested refresh rate and force it to operate at max available one instead. This is automatically configured on a G-Sync display, but can be manually configured without one. I am not familiar with modern AMD/ATi graphics cards so I'm not sure if they have a similar option in the driver but if they do that should resolve this issue.
As a workaround use custom display resolution created in CRU.
I had similar issue playing GTA IV with DXVK 1.10.1 on Windows 11, RX580 with Adrenalin 22.4.1. I created a custom 1920x1080 71Hz resolution for my desktop in Radeon Software. This resolution is detected by GTA IV but when it is selected the monitor is switched to 1920x1080 60Hz instead as reported by monitor's OSD and this incorrect 60Hz refresh rate is retained for desktop upon game exit.
However when I create custom resolution in CRU, restart driver, select it for desktop and select it in GTA IV then this custom CRU refresh rate is correctly applied in the game and retained for desktop. What is even more important all VSR modes within the game become selectable with new improved refresh rate instead of 60Hz.
For the record, Freesync completely solves this problem.
Ran into this problem after installing nimeZ drivers, solved it with CRU(set a "custom" resolution with automatic timings + proper native res/refresh and left it as the only "detailed resolution").
Maybe the problem is fixed with the update to the maxFrameRate option:
https://github.com/doitsujin/dxvk/blob/8573190c7dbda89528ec6ae5f6b650909c4d4151/dxvk.conf#L42-L53
From what i can see - this is a bug with Windows' ChangeDisplaySettings function, appearing not only in DXVK but many other OpenGL/Vulkan games where it's used to setup fullscreen. When calling it - Windows will reset display refresh rate to what's configured in the monitor's EDID as the "default" refresh rate, and many monitors default to 60 Hz for compatibility purposes. The only workaround for now is to use CRU to make an EDID override.
I can also confirm this issue happens to Windows 7, so it's not specific to newer versions.
@Raydonn @vlad54rus Do you know if this is still a issue to this day?
At least when testing on Windows 11 with a RTX 4080 i am not able to reproduce as Windows switches fine back from 60 to my desktops 120 when i exit Skyrim SE. So unsure if i am missing some detail to be able to reproduce or if something changed in Windows.
Edit: accidentally pinged Raydonn twice instead of you too vlad54rus
@Raydonn @vlad54rus Do you know if this is still a issue to this day? At least when testing on Windows 11 with a RTX 4080 i am not able to reproduce as Windows switches fine back from 60 to my desktops 120 when i exit Skyrim SE. So unsure if i am missing some detail to be able to reproduce or if something changed in Windows.
Edit: accidentally pinged Raydonn twice instead of you too vlad54rus
Hmm.. I've since upgraded my computer a bit so it's not on the same OS, CPU/GPU and driver combo as last time, but I can't seem to reproduce the issue anymore. Using DXVK no longer forces any refresh rate change on my monitors.
dxgi.dllx1 2021-02
Even though I've manually set my refresh rate to 120Hz and sometimes 144Hz for normal usage in Windows applications, whenever I run the DXVK wrapper on any game, it forces my refresh rate to 60Hz and it remains at 60Hz until I manually change it back to whatever refresh rate I had before.
Makes it kind of hard to enjoy DXVK when my refresh rate gets limited to 60Hz by the wrapper.
Edit: If it helps, I have a dual monitor setup that has the second one set at 60Hz. However, even when disconnected, DXVK forces the main monitor to 60Hz.
Software information
Skyrim SE / Guild Wars 2, but I'll just use Skyrim SE as an example.
System information
Apitrace file(s)
Couldn't get APItrace to run alongside DXVK. Crashes everytime.
Log files
dxgi.log
SkyrimSE_d3d11.log
SkyrimSE_dxgi.log